Blemished Organic Plugs Mystery Bag
Advanced search & filters
Current Filters
More Filters:
Body Jewelry
Regular Jewelry
Shirt sizes
Ring sizes
Defaults to contain ANY selected colors
Clearance Blemished Organic Plugs Mystery Bag
50% OFFSavings: Original price
Sold as a PAIR
50+ customers have this in their cart
  • Product # 21419
  • Material(s): OrganicGlassBoneHornStoneWood
  • Worn In: Ear lobe
  • Sizes offered: 8g, 6g, 4g, 2g, 0g, 00g/9.5mm, 00g/10mm, 7/16", 1/2", 9/16", 5/8", 11/16", 3/4", 13/16", 7/8", 15/16", 1", 1-7/16"
Love mystery bags? Love getting plugs for a great price? Then pick up some of these clearance plug grab bags! Each pack is a surprise!

Because of the large variety of designs, mystery grab bags may contain designs that are not shown in the photo.

Due to the blemished nature of the items and to preserve the mystery of the grab bags, we can not take individual pictures of the grab bags, or accept returns or exchanges.

Items in this bin are flawed, and priced accordingly. All pairs are still wearable.

Common reasons items are blemished:

  • Mismatched pairs (color, shape, size, or all three)
  • Wonky flares
  • Small chips, bubbles, or inclusions
  • Samples

Grab bags are available in either mixed materials or all stone. The mixed materials could include wood, stone, horn, bone, or glass and some bags may contain multiple pairs of the same material but all pairs will vary in style. Majority of pairs are double flare.

  • 10g through 1-3/16": contain 3 pairs of plugs
  • 1-1/4" through 2-3/4": contain 2 pairs of plugs
PLEASE NOTE: This item is crafted from organic material and the gauge can vary +/- up to 0.5mm
SPECIAL CARE: This item is made with wood. We recommend taking wood jewelry out before showering as water can ruin it.
Customer Photos
Similar Products
Customers Also Bought
Customer Reviews (364)
4.7 out of 5 stars
78% (348)
15% (65)
4% (17)
2% (7)
2% (7)
5 Posted on 2/1/2023    by holly
Verified purchase 1-11/16"  2 pair (all wood)
Very good deal! Got two very pretty and not heavily blemished or mismatched pairs. Amazing deal for those of us with huge lobes, as our jewelry gets expensive. Thanks again BAF!
Was this review helpful to you?
5 Posted on 12/30/2022    by Gabrielle
Verified purchase 7/16"  Mixed material (3 pair)
This is always a fun way to try new materials. Thank you!
Was this review helpful to you?
5 Posted on 11/16/2022    by cassandra
Verified purchase 5/8"  Stone (3 pair)
These blemish bags are always a win! My ears tend to fluctuate in sizes often so it's nice to have a lot of options for a cheap price
Was this review helpful to you?
5 Posted on 9/13/2022    by Cristina
Verified purchase 15/16"  Mixed material (3 pair)
This was the first mystery bag I ever purchased. All of them were double flares with no obvious blemishes. I loved all the plugs I received except for one. Which was a pair of black plugs with a white background in the front and a black star in the center. They were nice, just not my style. Second, a pair of orange stone plugs resembling carnelian, but not sure. Lastly a pair of black horn plugs with a nice pattern etched into it. The last two are lovely and my favorite out of the bunch. Looking forward to my next mystery bag!
Was this review helpful to you?
4 Posted on 9/9/2022    by Cristina
Verified purchase 13/16"  Mixed material (3 pair)
You take a chance when you buy mystery bags. I've bought others before and have liked most or all of the items I received. But, in this case I only liked 1 out of 3 items. It's doesn't matter though because these are "in between" plugs until I reach my next size so I'm not worried about it as I would probably only wear my favorite one if I did like the rest anyway. I received one wooden pair with a wolf face. It had minor imperfections with one of the carvings. One wooden pair of seahorses. Again, minor imperfections with cravings. Then the pair I like, blue stone plugs that have intricate dark blue webbing within it.
Was this review helpful to you?
Customer Questions & Answers

Don't see the answer you're looking for? Please log-in to post your question