Pinterest Blemished Organic Plugs Mystery Bag
Advanced search & filters
Current Filters
More Filters:
Body Jewelry
Regular Jewelry
Shirt sizes
Ring sizes
Defaults to contain ANY selected colors

Blemished Organic Plugs Mystery Bag

$7.48 - $14.98
50% OFFSavings: Original price

Blemished Organic Plugs Mystery Bag

$7.48 - $14.98
50% OFFSavings: Original price
Show mm sizes
Sold as a PAIR
38 customers have this in their cart
Product Description:

Because of the large variety of designs, mystery grab bags may contain designs that are not shown in the photo.

Due to the blemished nature of the items and to preserve the mystery of the grab bags, we can not take individual pictures of the grab bags, or accept returns or exchanges.

Items in this bin are flawed, and priced accordingly. All pairs are still wearable.

Common reasons items are blemished:

  • Mismatched pairs (color, shape, size, or all three)
  • Wonky flares
  • Small chips, bubbles, or inclusions
  • Samples

Grab bags are available in either mixed materials or all stone. The mixed materials could include wood, stone, horn, bone, or glass and some bags may contain multiple pairs of the same material but all pairs will vary in style. Majority of pairs are double flare.

  • 10g through 1-3/16": contain 3 pairs of plugs
  • 1-1/4" through 2-3/4": contain 2 pairs of plugs
PLEASE NOTE: This item is crafted from organic material and the gauge can vary +/- up to 0.5mm
SPECIAL CARE: This item is made with wood. We recommend taking wood jewelry out before showering as water can ruin it.
  • Product # 21419
  • Material(s): Glass, Bone, Horn, Stone, Wood
  • Worn In: Ear lobe
  • Sizes offered: 8g (3mm), 6g (4mm), 4g (5mm), 2g (6mm), 0g (8mm), 00g/9.5mm, 00g/10mm, 7/16" (11mm), 1/2" (12.5mm), 9/16" (14mm), 5/8" (16mm), 3/4" (~19mm)
  • Colors offered: null
Similar Products
Customer Photos
Customer Reviews (371)
4.7 out of 5 stars
78% (353)
15% (67)
4% (17)
2% (7)
2% (7)
5 Posted on 4/17/2024    by Amber
Verified purchase 1/2"  Stone (3 pair)
The mystery plugs I received were 10/10! So good! Three sets, & they were all nice, neutral colors that would match anything. Almost love them more than the other items I picked out myself & purchased. 😆
Was this review helpful to you?
5 Posted on 3/17/2024    by Alyssa
Verified purchase 9/16"  Stone (3 pair)
My goodness I snatched some more stone mystery bags and as always I am surprised and happy! I seemed to have gotten low grade fluorite (super purple, one has some blue and it's a GORGEOUS pair!) then I got what I think is some red tigers eye tunnels, every plug I couldn't tell what was off aside from coloring (which is natural) so they're all perfect for me!
Was this review helpful to you?
4 Posted on 2/9/2024    by Alyssa
Verified purchase 9/16"  Mixed material (3 pair)
Great bag, just got 2 plugs I already have which is unfortunate, but hey that's the thing about mystery bags, I'd buy another one still!
Was this review helpful to you?
4 Posted on 1/9/2024    by BELINDA
Verified purchase 7/8"  Stone (3 pair)
I was pleasantly happy with most of the stones I got out of three bags. Two sets of teardrops, while a nice surprise, are not 7/8". They barely measure 13/16" point and bottom and about 1/2" across the face. They don't have much in the way of flares, so these are far too small for me. They were pretty though. All of the plugs were varied, pretty well matched, and with minimal blemishes. I have a lot of earrings, so for the price it's a nice way to maybe find something new.
Was this review helpful to you?
5 Posted on 10/24/2023    by brandy
Verified purchase 0g  Mixed material (3 pair)
I love the mystery bags! I always get amazing items.
Was this review helpful to you?
5 Posted on 9/11/2023    by NR
Verified purchase 1/2"  Stone (3 pair)
Great as always! Got one pair that I already have, a pair of teardrop amethyst looking earrings with basically no flare, and a pair of hematite plugs that don't seem blemished at all
Was this review helpful to you?
5 Posted on 12/24/2023    by Neisha-Rose
Verified purchase 1/2"  Stone (3 pair)
Got a labradorite, these amazing mauve single flare with small flares, and opal plugs with small flares. All look amazing! Just gotta not lose them lol def worth it
Was this review helpful to you?
5 Posted on 2/1/2023    by holly
Verified purchase 1-11/16"  2 pair (all wood)
Very good deal! Got two very pretty and not heavily blemished or mismatched pairs. Amazing deal for those of us with huge lobes, as our jewelry gets expensive. Thanks again BAF!
Was this review helpful to you?
5 Posted on 12/30/2022    by Gabrielle
Verified purchase 7/16"  Mixed material (3 pair)
This is always a fun way to try new materials. Thank you!
Was this review helpful to you?
5 Posted on 11/16/2022    by cassandra
Verified purchase 5/8"  Stone (3 pair)
These blemish bags are always a win! My ears tend to fluctuate in sizes often so it's nice to have a lot of options for a cheap price
Was this review helpful to you?
Customer Questions & Answers

Don't see the answer you're looking for? Please log-in to post your question
Customers Also Bought