Pinterest Plugs Mystery Bag | Gauges Plugs Stretched Lobe
Advanced search & filters
Current Filters
More Filters:
Body Jewelry
Regular Jewelry
Shirt sizes
Ring sizes
Defaults to contain ANY selected colors

Plugs Mystery Bag

$14.95 - $29.95

Plugs Mystery Bag

$14.95 - $29.95
Show mm sizes
Sold as a PAIR
19 customers have this in their cart
Product Description:

Because of the large variety of designs, mystery grab bags will contain designs that are NOT shown in the photo.

Each grab bag could contain a mixture of silicone, wood, stone, horn, bone, or glass plugs. All bags will have a variety of designs, and though there may be multiple pairs of the same material, they will all look different. Majority of pairs are double flare.

  • 10g through 1-3/16": contain 3 pairs of plugs
  • 1-1/4" through 2-3/4": contain 2 pairs of plugs

To preserve the mystery of our mystery bags we cannot take individual pictures of the items in them, or accept returns or exchanges.

SPECIAL CARE: This item is made with wood. We recommend taking wood jewelry out before showering as water can ruin it.
THIS IS A LIMITED ITEM! Limited jewelry is usually re-stocked much less frequently and is harder for us to get from the manufacturer. So get it while you can, while it's available!
  • Product # 21413
  • Material(s): Glass, Bone, Horn, Stone, Wood, Silicone
  • Worn In: Ear lobe
  • Sizes offered: 8g (3mm), 6g (4mm), 2g (6mm), 0g (8mm), 00g/10mm, 1/2" (12.5mm), 9/16" (14mm), 5/8" (16mm), 11/16" (~18mm), 3/4" (~19mm), 13/16" (20.5mm), 7/8" (22mm), 1-7/16" (36.5mm)
  • Colors offered:
Similar Products
Customer Photos
Customer Reviews (88)
4.5 out of 5 stars
65% (49)
25% (19)
5% (4)
1% (1)
3% (2)
5 Posted on 8/6/2023    by Renee
Verified purchase 9/16"  3 pair
Got some really cool and unique pieces, would recommend trying at least once!
Was this review helpful to you?
5 Posted on 6/28/2023    by Rachel
Verified purchase 6g  3 pair
A fun way to get some pieces! I got one rubber pair, and two stone
Was this review helpful to you?
5 Posted on 6/14/2023    by Sarah
Verified purchase 8g  3 pair
Fantastic value and beautiful plugs.
Was this review helpful to you?
5 Posted on 3/2/2023
Verified purchase 2g  3 pair
I made a request for silicone or stone and got all stone, I'm so happy that I was able to get all stone 💕 some of them had blemishes but that's okay :)
BAF comment: We have reached out to the customer to help resolve this issue
Was this review helpful to you?
4 Posted on 1/7/2023    by V
Verified purchase 00g/10mm  3 pair
Fun wooden plugs, snowflake obsidian, and polaris tunnels! Wonderful!
Was this review helpful to you?
5 Posted on 12/7/2022    by Elizabeth
Verified purchase 0g  3 pair
I some great pieces. I like the mystery bag since it takes me out of my norms.
Was this review helpful to you?
5 Posted on 10/4/2022    by Madelyn
Verified purchase 5/8"  3 pair
Got wonderful glass and stone plugs with minimal defect.
Was this review helpful to you?
4 Posted on 9/19/2022    by Megan
Verified purchase 00g/10mm  3 pair
2 of the 3 pairs were fantastic. This is the second time I've ordered the mystery bag. In this order I received: 1 pair of glass colour front single flares plugs (green fronts), 1 pair of opalite single flair plugs (Not perfectly matched but gorgeous nonetheless) and an actual mystery pair of double flare stone plugs. Took a star off because the double flare pair are smaller than 10mm. I highly recommend the mystery bags as an easy way to add to your collection.
Was this review helpful to you?
5 Posted on 7/13/2022    by Sarena
Verified purchase 0g  3 pair
Got 3 df stone pairs in opalite, adventurine, and what I think is fluorite. All very pretty, opalite had larger flares which were a little harder to get in but I still really like them. Def would get again, also seen in other reviews that sometimes requests for certain things like smaller flares or different materials can be made so that's great
Was this review helpful to you?
5 Posted on 4/10/2022    by Natalie
Verified purchase 0g  3 pair
Pretty and unique
Was this review helpful to you?
Customer Questions & Answers

Don't see the answer you're looking for? Please log-in to post your question
Customers Also Bought